Hours Of Operations Payless ShoeSource New York Setauket Payless ShoeSource Hours of Operation and Locations in Setauket, NY 4.9 - 206 votes 1 Locations in Setauket www.payless.com Payless ShoeSource Hours Category: Accessories Shoes Payless ShoeSource - Setauket, NY 11733 Port Haven Plaza 5020 Nesconset Hwy(631) 474-8468 View Store Details Recommend For You Staples Kmart Kroger Big Lots Sunglass Hut JCPenney Cato Kay Jewelers Ross Dress for Less Macy's